It seems all the rage on some blogs, especially in the USA at the moment to criticise venture capital. Of course its a big industry and covers a wide range of players. However what I dont understand is early stage venture capital being criticised as greedy or to be avoided at all costs.
I'm the first to point out that venture capital is an expensive form of finance and if you can set-up and grow a business without it great. Some internet and web entrepreneurs would indeed be well advised to "bootstrap" and get going without vc or Angel finance, at least till they can prove a following, a business model or just show traction in a market.
Such advice ia however hard for some technology starts that need investment of some sort as they are going to need to patent devices or processes, build and test prototypes. Through all this they may not have anything to sell, often for some years. For them, short of the increasingly rare grants they might attract, venture capital is what they need or almost all there is out there.
Further, people forget or never look at, the risk in venture investing, which of course balances out the high returns a vc might get on some of its investments. Most venture capital, despite clever use these days of legal agreements and loan and other instruments in the deal, is still un-secured lending. Or put it another way if you go bust we loose most if not all our investment.
There are also, sadly, too few venture capital funds focussed on real early stage (sub £1m or $2m investments). The main reason for this is the even higher risk of new-start and spin-outs and poor track record of some funds due to the additional risk in the very early stage stuff. Some reports and blogs are critical of such funds saying they are not "commecial" and dont make real-world returns. Well the fact is these funds are often set up with a double bottom-line or dual objective. Simply, they have to help economic development and fill a gap in the market as well as hit a financial return.
So please next time you hear someone complain about venture capital, especially early stage send them to me and lets have an informed debate.